Secrets of Andy Cohen's Clubhouse Revealed

On this eclectic shelf is a trio of odd gifts: an Andy doll from "Flipping Out" star Jenni Pulos, a likeness of Jake Shears of Scissor Sisters, and a knife from "The Shahs of Sunset's" GG.

Who knew the Housewives wrangler was a baseball lover? He’s such a die-hard St. Louis Cardinals fan that May 10, 2013, was named Andy Cohen Night at Busch Stadium. The Cardinals had this bobblehead made in his honor, which stands guard over a bat signed by Ozzie Smith.

In 2012 the Real Housewife of Orange County had her implants removed and bequeathed them to Cohen. They’re accessorized with Patti LaBelle’s half-eaten Life Saver, Lindsay Lohan’s cigarette butt, and Julie Andrews' used tea bag.

A longtime veteran of the Clubhouse, this Justin Bieber doll got a chic new wrap dress after a visit from designer Diane von Furstenberg.

The singer urinated in the "WWHL" dressing-room trash can, so naturally Cohen had the eau de Gaga bottled. Next to it is something sentimental: Cohen’s childhood encyclopedias. “Yeah, from the ’70s!" he says. "They look so pretty on the shelf."

Check out this double-sided doll of ’70s ­comedian Flip Wilson and his alter ego ­Geraldine Jones. “It had been on Flip’s side, but I was getting so many tweets saying, ‘Why do you have a Bill Cosby doll?’ ” says Cohen. Next to it: a strain of "Connie Chung" pot – from Connie Chung herself.