Can You Tell Evan Peters, Michael Cera, and Andy Samberg Apart?

Now, who is this mustachioed fellow?

Now, who is this guy?

Now it gets a little harder... Who is this pasty shirtless person?

Who's this weirdo staring angstily at a rat while bathing fully clothed?

Now, who's this idiot getting champagne all over his perfectly good suit?

Who's the gorgeous face behind all the neat skull makeup?

Now, who's this gorgeous fella in drag?

Who is cradling this cactus so tenderly?

Who is this mysterious weeping man?

Now who's this weirdly gold painted dude?

And who is this goggle-eyed silver man?

And now, who is this sun-spectacled shirtless driver?

And who's this smooth criminal?

And finally, who is the center stud in the blue turtleneck?