Manning vs. Brady: Who Is The Greatest Modern Quarterback?

Peyton Manning and Tom Brady is without question the greatest quarterback rivalry ever. Brady has 4 Super Bowls and 2 NFL MVPs. Manning has 1 Super Bowl, 5 MVPs and all the records. Each has an argument to be the best ever. Who's your choice?

Sam Robinson
Created by Sam Robinson (User Generated Content*)User Generated Content is not posted by anyone affiliated with, or on behalf of, Playbuzz.com.
On Jan 26, 2016

How much to you think the Patriots' multiple on-field cheating scandals affected Brady's performance and legacy?

Calculating results

To win 1 game at a neutral site, who in his prime would you want quarterbacking your team?

Calculating results

Whose best season was better? 2013 Manning (55 TDs, 5,477 yards, 10 INTs) or 2007 Brady (50 TDs, 4,806 yards, 8 INTs)?

Calculating results

Put Manning with Bill Belichick and Brady with Manning's 5 coaches. How much different are their careers?

Calculating results

How much does Manning's performance after 4 neck surgeries on a different team enhance his legacy?

Calculating results

Which do you value more: Brady's historic playoff success (record 6 Super Bowl starts) or Manning's consistent dominance (record 5 MVPs)?

Calculating results

Who's had the higher degree of difficulty during their career?

Calculating results

Who's made the greater impact on the game?

Calculating results

What do you make of Manning's teams' struggles in the playoffs?

Calculating results

How would you summarize Brady's success in the playoffs?

Calculating results

Who's had the better weapons throughout their career?

Calculating results

So, who's this generation's greatest quarterback?

Calculating results

Which head-to-head number is more significant: Brady's 11-6 record against Manning, or Manning's 3-1 edge vs. Brady in AFC title games?

Calculating results
These are 10 of the World CRAZIEST Ice Cream Flavors
Created by Tal Garner
On Nov 18, 2021